Cumbria Crack

Jury in trial of teens who deny Penrith robbery “plot” starts deliberations

The ATM at Barclays Bank in Penrith at which the woman was robbed

A JURY in the trial of two teenagers who deny being involved in a plot to commit robbery has retired to consider its verdicts.

Paul Stuchfield, 19, and a 14-year-old boy are on trial at Carlisle Crown Court. Both deny one charge alleging conspiracy to rob on January 16 this year.

The prosecution allege both males were part of a prior agreement to carry out a robbery which did then occur at a Penrith town centre cashpoint at around 6pm on that date. The female victim was left shocked and suffered puncture wounds to her lower body after being threatened by a 16-year-old blade-carrying youth who – jurors have heard – admits carrying out that crime.

A girl has told the court she heard Stuchfield and the 14-year-old boy speak about carrying out a robbery in Penrith’s McDonald’s restaurant shortly before the crime took place.

But, giving evidence, Stuchfield, of Kirkoswald, near Penrith, told jurors there was no such conversation, insisting: “I did not conspire to rob.” And, when the 14-year-old was asked while giving his evidence whether he was part of the alleged robbery agreement, he replied: “No.”

This morning (WED), barristers delivered speeches to the jury of 10 women and two men. Prosecutor Alaric Walmsley said to them: “The only question is whether the robbery was planned or whether, as the defence would have it, simply (the 16-year-old) was acting on his own.”

After Judge James Adkin summed up evidence in the case, jurors retired to begin their deliberations.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More